As you read my Derby analysis, be aware of my record: I've covered it for 12 years and only hit the winner twice (Fusaichi Pegasus in 2000 and Street Sense in 2007). But I do the research every year and I take my shot, so here goes...
The first thing I do is eliminate the "throwouts", horses I think have no chance to win the race. They are long shots for a reason. I understand that anamolies like Mine That Bird happen but I'm not gonna bet on it. The horses below would have to get a perfect trip and run the race of their lives and that's not enough for me to wager on. So toss:
- Daddy Long Legs (horrible post, rookie jock, 12th on only dirt start)
- Optimizer (9th in two of last three races)
- Rousing Sermon (lacks speed, poor record on dirt)
- Trinniberg (distance limitations)
- Done Talking (never run remotely fast enough to win here)
- Sabercat (mediocre last two times out)
- Liaison (last three races stink. Baffert says new track will make difference but...)
That leaves me with 13 horses. Now I apply my Beyer filter. 18 of the last 20 Derby winners have had a Beyer speed figure of at least 98 before winning the race. The streak was 17 straight years until two of the last three winners didn't measure up. But I still think this is a useful screening device.
The biggest horse eliminated here is Union Rags. His fastest Beyer of his career is 95 and that just doesn't fit the traditional speed profile of a Derby winner. NBC Sports horse-racing expert Randy Moss explained during the week that Union Rags' numbers need to be put in perspective because he had to run very wide during his losses and with a better trip he would've put up the required number. That makes sense, but he didn't hit the number even in the races he won so I have to toss him as my winner.
Other horses who don't meet this threshold are:
- Hansen
- Take Charge Indy
- I'll Have Another
- Prospective
- Went the Day Well
That leaves me with seven horses. Now the fun begins.
I eliminate Creative Cause because his trainer says he doesn't like to be crowded and that seems inevitable during this race. Also he hasn't trained particularly well this week.
I toss Alpha because he acted up the in the gate last time here and will be first to load. I don't like that combo.
As much as I like local trainer Dale Romans, I can't bet Dullahan because his three races on dirt are 3rd, 8th and 4th. I like his closing style but he seems like more of a grass/synthetic horse. But this is one where I wouldn't mind being wrong!
I'm gonna eliminate Daddy Nose Best because I'm not sure who he's beaten. Plus 8 races as a 2-year is far from the normal race background of recent champs.
I'm very tempted by El Padrino at a good price but he seems just slightly less impressive than my final two.
Bodemeister is the fastest horse in the race and if he runs anything close to his race in the Arkansas Derby he'll be your winner... that race was epic! But I think the speed duel up front will ultimately cause him to go out too fast. Plus he never raced as a two-year old which is one of the few Derby no-no's still out there. He's a horse who either wins or doesn't finish top five and I'm going to reluctantly go with the latter. So that leaves only one horse left...
Gemologist is my selection to win the 2012 Kentucky Derby. He's unbeaten in five lifetime races and that includes two victories around two turns here at Churchill Downs. His speed figures have improved every race and trainer Todd Pletcher says he still has something in the tank to get even better. His mid-pack running style fits the race and I really liked his finish in the Wood Memorial... when Alpha came up on him, Gemologist refused to lose. That's an attitude that will serve him well here.
Gemologist is like Boise State football in that his record is great but people question who he's beaten. I get that criticism but I think that in general unbeaten horses do well in the Derby. 22 horses have entered the race without a loss and 7 have won. That's 32%! Not too shabby. Meanwhile 13 of those horses finished in the money. That's 59%!!
So I'll take Gemologist on top. As for filling out my exotics, I'm going to include Union Rags simply because the trainers on the backside have been nearly unanimous that he's the best horse in the race. They know more than me so I'll trust them. I'll also use I'll Have Another, Daddy Nose Best and El Padrino.
For the record, my official predicted order of finish is:
1. Gemologist
2. Union Rags
3. I'll Have Another
4. Daddy Nose Best
5. El Padrino
Good luck at the windows!









